Work Items are Made Up
One thing that is a pain in teams is splitting work items. People are reluctant to do so, likely because of inconvenient tooling or the feeling of having to start over. Today, I want to elaborate on a concept that makes this more approachable. Generally, there is one important fact to hold in mind about chunks of work: all of them are made up. When you split your work into foreseeable bits, it is artificial. Their boundaries are arbitrary. You live in a constant stream of time and work. All you ever do is pull chunks out and prioritize them. I do not necessarily mean an active process. You do that every day, every second of being awake. When you turn on the TV, you prioritized that over a gazillion other available actions. None of that takes conscious effort. How does that knowledge help us for work? A lot, actually. Once we truly understand that concept, “good enough” within our teams gains substance. Because the boundary is arbitrary, nothing is lost when an item ends. We do not have to think this further. The bigger chunk stays as a container and we continue iterating in it. There is a next item. There can be a follow-up. Being able to trust that the process will generate the next slice massively reduces the potential to overthink scope. This mindset also makes it easier to split issues. Often, there can be smaller vertical slices, but it is challenging to recognize them. It takes brain power. In my experience, usually, people are afraid of losing control when splitting. That they will lack context with a slice. Now, hold on, remember my earlier words. We learned that work items are arbitrary. A fact that enables us to let go of that anxiety. That small split makes as much sense as the big chunk it came from. Why would we assume we hit the right spot initially? Where and why was that sliced out? A fragment that feels right for me may not feel right for the next person. It may not even feel right for future me. The boundaries of a work item are a choice. Make it deliberately and adapt it freely. Our guiding plan should be to vertically slice so small that every team member has at most a mini adventure, but never a death march. Take “watering your plants” for example. How do you typically prioritize and triage that project? Take a moment to reflect on it. Do you restrict it to a room? Or do you make one effort for the whole flat? Do you do it flower by flower? Once you have an answer, ask yourself why that is. Why did you choose exactly that level of specificity? Usually, without deeper reflection, it just naturally felt right. Let's do an exercise together. Since we know that work items are made up, we can scale them indefinitely in all dimensions. Let's do this for “watering the plants”:
- Tilt the watering can
- Water the tulip on the sideboard in the office
- Water all plants in the office
- Water all plants in the flat
- Have a nice, liveable home
- Have shelter
- Survive
From a universal perspective, any slice is as good as the next one. Where is yours? Typically, it sits somewhere between “Water all plants in the office” and “Water all plants in the flat.” This is a subjective choice we make subconsciously. Not something that is naturally enforced. Let's continue our thought experiment: What would that look like for a toddler? Would they understand the whole context of “Water all plants in the flat?” Could they consciously endure such a task? Would they be able to keep the infrastructure (getting water basically) running? Most likely not. Or, at least, the risk of them not watering all plants (giving up, overlooking something), making a mess, or being physically not able to (height, strength, endurance) would be high. Where would you set the pin for them in the earlier list? If they have never touched a watering can, I would probably even go for “tilt the watering can.” At least I can imagine me saying: “See, pick up the can. Place it here. Tilt it and water flows out. You stop once the whole soil is wet.” That means we can, in fact, find the sweet spot. We understand the concept subconsciously. More good news: we can even formulate the rationale behind it. Psychologists have a name for this sweet spot. It is called the zone of proximal development. It is the space between what someone can already do alone and what they can do with guidance. Humans like to have tasks that are not free of risk (boring). At the same time, they should not be downright risky (overwhelming). Somewhere between having an approachable plan, but not a complete solution. We wish to think about it a little. We intend to have a mini adventure. A tiny bit of room for creativity and problem-solving. The task “water all plants in the flat” is exactly that. You know where the watering can usually is. You do not know, however, for certain that it is there. Maybe someone put it somewhere else for instance. Furthermore, you can roughly assume the number of plants, but that takes a bit of consideration. You need a plan for going around the room to remember where you have already been to not forget one. It is a low-risk, mundane adventure. But it is an adventure. The toddler, on the other hand, wants to have the same, just on a different scale. Holding the can and tilting it is something that they need to understand and practice. It is, again, a low-risk adventure. Luckily, we don't have to deal with toddlers at work. However, this also makes the right size far less obvious and more nuanced. The group and even you yourself make countless assumptions. How often did you underestimate a task and ended up being paralysed and prone to procrastinating because it turned out the adventure was too wild? One's “adventure” is an ordeal for others. You might rightfully ask: what happens if it is not “your” mini adventure? If it is mundane and solved for you? Generally speaking, making an adventure more adventurous is always possible. Typically, this is where you step into the realms of leadership and enablement. Your comfort zone ends where you have to teach and coach others. What can you do so that a similar scenario would also be as boring for them the next time? Of course, we try to find tools so that everyone feels empowered enough to speak up. That everyone makes the right assumptions about themselves. That the whole group is mentally present and actively engaged. But we also should simply say: “Let's vertically slice these work items so small that every person on the team has a mini adventure at most and never a death march.”